Skip to main content

Table 2 Characterizing included articles regarding approach, coherence, and NTS included

From: Examining non-technical skills for ad hoc resuscitation teams: a scoping review and taxonomy of team-related concepts

Author, Year

Description

[Coherence score]

Interpersonal Skills

Cognitive Skills

Communication

Leadership

Teamwork

Briefing & Planning

Resource Manage

Advice seeking

Stress or Fatigue Management

Followership

Debriefing

Decision-making

Situational Awareness

Mental Readiness

Adaptation

Shared Mental Model1

Driscoll & Vincent, 1992

Quantitative, observational

[2]

 

*

*

           

Xiao et al., 1996

Quantitative, observational

[3]

*

 

*

           

Stohler, 1998

Qualitative, interviews

[2]

*

 

*

           

Cooper & Wakelam, 1999

Quantitative, observational

[3]

*

*

            

Meerabeau, 1999

Review

[3]

*

*

*

           

Williams et al., 1999

Quantitative, observational

[3]

*

 

*

*

*

        

*

Bergs et al., 2005

Quantitative and qualitative, observational [2]

*

*

            

Cole & Crichton, 2006

Qualitative, interviews and observation [3]

*

*

*

*

*

*

        

Hunt et al., 2007

Review

[3]

*

*

*

 

*

   

*

   

*

 

Campeau, 2008

Qualitative, interviews

[2]

*

*

*

 

*

    

*

*

 

*

 

Hicks et al., 2008

Quantitative survey, importance of NTS [3]

*

*

*

 

*

    

*

*

   

Hoyer et al., 2009

Quantitative, observational

[0]

*

*

  

*

         

Manser, 2009

Review

[3]

*

*

*

     

*

 

*

 

*

*

Andersen et al., 2010

Qualitative, interviews

[3]

*

*

  

*

         

Capella et al., 2010

Pre/post intervention, clinical setting

[3]

*

*

*

*

      

*

   

Hunziker et al., 2010

Controlled trial, simulation setting [2]

 

*

            

Westli et al., 2010

Quantitative, observational

[3]

*

 

*

       

*

  

*

Sarcevic et al., 2011

Qualitative, interview

[3]

 

*

*

      

*

    

Høyer et al., 2011

Controlled trial, clinical setting [2]

*

*

*

*

*

         

Hunziker et al., 2011

Review

[3]

*

*

*

      

*

    

Steinemann et al., 2011

Pre/post intervention, clinical setting [1]

*

*

*

 

*

 

*

  

*

*

   

Jankouskas et al., 2011

Pre/post intervention, simulation setting [0]

  

*

 

*

     

*

   

Miller et al., 2011

Description of intervention delivery [0]

*

*

*

       

*

   

Norris & Lockey, 2012

Review

[3]

*

*

*

   

*

*

*

 

*

*

  

Sarcevic et al., 2012

Qualitative, observational

[3]

*

*

*

      

*

*

   

Cooper et al., 2013

Review

[3]

          

*

   

Castelao et al., 2013

Review

[3]

*

*

*

*

          

Petrosniack & Hicks, 2013

Review

[3]

*

 

*

   

*

 

*

*

*

*

 

*

Shields & Flin, 2013

Review

[3]

*

*

*

      

*

*

   

Clarke et al., 2014

Description of intervention delivery [1]

*

*

*

*

*

    

*

    

Gjeraa et al., 2014

Review

[3]

*

*

*

   

*

  

*

*

   

Rasmussen et al., 2014

Quantitative survey, team experiences [3]

*

 

*

          

*

Clements et al., 2015

Pre/post intervention, clinical setting [2]

*

*

       

*

*

   

Gillman et al., 2016

Description of intervention delivery [1]

*

*

*

 

*

     

*

   

Lorello et al., 2016

Experimental design, simulation setting [3]

*

*

*

        

*

 

*

Maluso et al., 2016

Quantitative, observational

[0]

*

*

*

           

Holly et al., 2016

Review

[3]

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

  

*

*

 

*

 

Steinemann et al., 2016

Pre/post intervention, clinical setting [0]

*

*

*

 

*

 

*

*

*

*

*

  

*

Steinemann et al., 2017

Controlled trial, simulation setting [0]

   

*

         

*

Calder et al., 2017

Qualitative, interviews and observation [3]

*

 

*

       

*

  

*

Johnson et al.,

2017

Quantitative, observational

[3]

*

*

        

*

  

*

Myers et al., 2017

Experimental design, simulation setting [2]

      

*

       

El Shafy et al., 2018

Quantitative, observational

[3]

*

*

            

Ghazali et al., 2018

Quantitative, observational

[3]

*

*

*

   

*

       

Hicks & Petrosoniak,

2018

Review

[3]

*

*

*

*

*

 

*

  

*

*

*

*

*

O’Neill et al., 2018

Review

[2]

*

*

*

 

*

*

    

*

  

*

Sullivan et al., 2018

Pre/post intervention, simulation setting [0]

*

*

*

 

*

 

*

  

*

*

   

Herzberg et al., 2019

Quantitative, observational

[1]

*

*

*

 

*

    

*

*

   

Lazzara et al., 2019

Review

[3]

*

*

*

*

*

       

*

 

Murphy et al., 2019

Qualitative, interviews

[3]

*

*

*

    

*

  

*

  

*

Coggins et al., 2020

Quantitative, observational and survey [3]

        

*

     

Cormack et al., 2020

Review

[1]

*

*

*

 

*

    

*

*

   

Dagnell, 2020

Commentary

[1]

 

*

*

           

Dumas et al., 2020

Quantitative, observational

[3]

*

*

*

 

*

    

*

*

   

Fernandez et al., 2020

Controlled trial, simulation and live resuscitation [3]

 

*

            

Gilmartin et al., 2020

Quality improvement report

[3]

        

*

     

Kristiansen et al., 2020

Pre/Post intervention, live resuscitation [0]

*

*

*

           

Lapierre et al., 2020

Review

[3]

  

*

           

Sherman et al., 2020

Qualitative, observational

[2]

*

*

*

       

*

   

Armstrong et al., 2021

Pre/Post intervention, simulation [2]

*

*

*

 

*

    

*

*

   

Petrosoniak et al., 2021

Quantitative, observational

[3]

*

*

*

       

*

  Â